SMALL
SCALE PRODUCTION
|
|
Jonathan Scurlock, Project Manager with North East Community Forests |
LONG TERM GOAL: Yes, we all want to have enough biodiesel to run our vehicle. Our automobile consumes more energy than anything else we own. Our fuel costs are high and at the same time our vehicle pollutes the air and helps to deplete the world's non-renewable resources. Burning petroleum also contributes to global warming. Our goal should be the production of enough biodiesel to power our car. Like most goals, there's a step by step way of getting there. |
LARGE SCALE PRODUCTION: A large scale production of biodiesel requires a large investment and mistakes can be costly. Doing your first batches of biodiesel with 20 gallons of waste oil is not the best way to learn the process. |
|
SMALL SCALE PRODUCTION: A setup that produces about a half gallon of biodiesel is a way that lets you learn about the process without a large investment of equipment or a need for large quantities of oil. | |
ALTERNATIVE USES: Most of us think of biodiesel as just an alternative for running our diesel truck or car. Unfortunately, most of us do not have a diesel powered vehicle (at least not yet). However, we still want to try making some biodiesel. If we make small batches, we can use the biodiesel in place of lamp oil. We like to use our biodiesel as a cleaning solvent. It works great at cutting through grease. |
|
LAMP OIL: A half gallon of biodiesel can be used in oil lamps or tiki torches. |
|
|
Kerosene Heater: Biodiesel should be able to replace kerosene in items like lanterns or kerosene heaters. Kerosene has carbon chains that are 12 to 15 carbon atoms long. It is the fraction of petroleum that vaporizes between 150°C and 275°C. Biodiesel has carbon chains that are about 12 to 18 carbons long. |
Deisel Generator: Many electric generators run off of diesel. A small scale production of biodiesel could fuel one of these generators. |
PROCEDURE FOR SMALL SCALE
PRODUCTION |
|
The image below shows our strategy, which is to use amounts that are convenient through the whole process. For example, we start with a 1.4L (48 oz) bottle of vegetable oil. Some fryers hold a maximum of 1.5 liters, so the 1.4 liters is the perfect size. After the oil gets used, it can be stored back in the same bottle. When ready for conversion, it can be mixed with a 0.25 L (12 oz) bottle of methanol (and lye) and placed in a 2L flask. No partially empty bottles are left over. | |
|
|
LOCATION TO DO CONVERSION: We prefer to make biodiesel outside. If we spill something, it might hurt the grass some but a nice countertop or table will not be stained.
|
|
FIRST TIME: When first learning about making biodiesel, it is always recommended to begin with new (unused) cooking oil. That simplifies the process. That's how we will start. We will begin with a 48 fluid ounce (1.42 Liter) bottle of vegetable cooking oil. We will use a 2 liter Erlenmeyer flask and an electric heating element. (A link to the complete equipment list will be at the bottom of this page) |
|
WARM UP OIL: Pour the oil into the flask and turn the electric heater to low. We need to warm up the oil for a couple of reasons. First, the heating will make the oil less viscous so it will stir more easily. Second, the heat helps the conversion to biodiesel go faster. | |
TEMPERATURE: Using a thermometer bring the temperature to between 120 to 130°F which is about 50°C. This will feel hot but not too hot to touch. Instead of an electric heater, you could set the flask in hot water. Your hot tap water is close to this temperature. |
|
CREATION OF METHOXIDE: Methoxide is made from a mixture of methanol and lye (sodium hydroxide). It is the most dangerous step of the process because methoxide is very corrosive. Notice the goggles and the gloves in the picture. Below is the equipment for the next step. It consists of a 250 mL polyethylene bottle, lye (Sodium hydroxide [NaOH]), a 12 oz (354 mL) bottle of gas antifreeze (methanol), a balance that can measure to one tenth of a gram, splash proof goggles, chemical resistant gloves, a funnel, and a spatula (or small spoon). | |
Some Bottles of Lye Lie: When you buy lye (sodium hydroxide) you have to be careful to get the pure form of the lye. Many types have other chemicals in it. The bottles shown came from ACE Hardware. They did have pure lye. The "lye" bottles at Home Depot and Walmart had additional ingredients. So be sure to read the ingredients and only go with one that only lists sodium hydroxide. | |
METHANOL (Methyl alcohol): The methanol needs to be close to 100% methanol. If exposed to the air, the methanol will absorb water, which will block the biodiesel conversion. Pure methanol is sold as gas-line antifreeze because it absorbs water in the gasoline and prevents the water from freezing. This is not the cheapest source of methanol but is convenient for our small scale production. Another source is racing fuel methanol, which is much cheaper per gallon. Don't get the "ISO DRY"; that is isopropyl alcohol and won't work. |
|
SPLASH RESISTANT GOGGLES: These goggles fit snug to the face, which prevents liquid from getting to the eyes. These goggles also have special vents that let air in but keep liquids out. Be sure to wear these as you make up the methoxide. |
|
SET UP FOR WEIGHING: Here is the setup again. The procedure is to place five grams of sodium hydroxide (lye) in the funnel and then add about half the contents of the methanol (washes the lye into the bottle). When the empty bottle and funnel are setting on the balance, the display will read a certain mass. You could calculate what 5 addition grams will make it weigh or press the "on/off zero" button (lower right) and that will set the display to zero. Then you just need to add enough lye to make the balance read 5.0 grams. Literature says to add 3.5 grams of lye for every liter. Since we have 1.4 liters, that makes it 5.0 grams. |
|
WEIGH OUT LYE: Open the lye bottle and using a spatula or small spoon, add sodium hydroxide until the balance reads between 4.8 and 5.2 grams, with 5.0 grams being ideal. If some spills on the balance, brush it off but be sure to wipe it up later. This is where having the balance sit on a sheet of newpaper would be handy. Any spills could be caught on the newpaper and disposed of more easily. Be sure to close the bottle of lye as soon as you get the right amount weighed. Lye will absorb water out of the air making it heavier and less effective. Be sure to be wearing goggles and gloves. |
|
WEIGH OUT LYE (using bigger bottle): Lately, instead of the smaller (250mL) bottle, I've been using a half liter plastic (HDPE) bottle, which had been a bottle that rubbing alcohol had come in. The larger bottle will allow you to pour the whole methanol bottle into it. Again, be sure to wear goggles. |
|
Pour methanol into NaOH: At this point 5 grams of lye (NaOH) will be in the funnel and bottle. Take the bottle off the balance. Open the methanol (gas antifreeze) bottle and pour some into the funnel. This will rinse the granules of lye down into the bottle. Continue adding methanol until the white bottle is about 3/4 full. Put the cap on the white polyethylene bottle and the methanol bottle. (Again, we're always trying to keep moisture in the air from being absorbed.) (If you are using the larger white plastic bottle, you can pour in the whole methanol bottle.) |
|
Dissolve NaOH in the methanol: Close the lid. Be sure to be wearing goggles and gloves. Tip bottle back and forth until the NaOH dissolves. This might take about five minutes. The NaOH reacts with the methanol (CH3OH) to form a powerful substance called methoxide CH3ONa. The bottle will get warm as the NaOH (lye) dissolves. | |
Check temperature: Check to see if the temperature of the cooking oil is between 120 to 130° Fahrenheit (50°C). | |
Place Flask on Magnetic Stirrer: The flask can now be placed on the magnetic stirrer. Be sure to put the magnetic bar (also called magnetic flea) in the flask. To keep the temperature between 120 and 130°F shine a spotlight or heat lamp on the mixture. Later, if the temperature goes too high, move the light farther away. | |
Pour Methoxide into the oil: Open the flip-top and squirt it into the oil. (If using the larger bottle, it won't have a flip-top). Again be sure to be wearing goggles and gloves. | |
Add remaining methanol: If you used the smaller white plastic bottle, the gas-line antifreeze bottle (methanol) still has methanol in it. Pour the remaining methanol into the flask containg the oil and methoxide. This extra methanol helps to convert more of the oil to biodiesel.
|
|
STIR MIXTURE: Turn on the magnetic stirrer to mix the methoxide, methanol, and oil. If you turn up the stirrer too fast, the magnet bar may get unstable and jump around without stirring. So adjust the speed to get good stirring but slow enough to keep the bar from jumping instead of spinning. Stirring time is normally listed as 2 hours. Some biodiesel will be produced in minutes, but to get maximum biodiesel, 2 hours is recommended. Keep eye on temperature and adjust the distance of the spotlight (or heat lamp) to keep temperature near the 120-130 degree Fahrenheit range. |
|
SEPARATORY FUNNEL: The pear-shaped glassware is called a separatory funnel because it is good for separating liquids that split into two layers. The stopcock at the bottom of the separatory funnel makes it easy to drain off the lower liquid. In the biodiesel process the methoxide reacts with the oil and makes two products. One is glycerin and the other is biodiesel. The glycerin will sink to the bottom. A separatory funnel makes it easier to drain off the glycerin. |
|
Pour Product into Separatory Funnel: Use a standard funnel to help get the mixture into the large separatory funnel. We first didn't use a separatory funnel because of its cost. Without it, getting the glycerin separated from the biodiesel required siphoning or pouring off the biodiesel, which was sloppy and wasteful. The separatory funnel will allow the glycerin to be easily drained out. Later when we add water, it will be easy to drain off the water. We found a much cheaper vendor of the separatory funnel, so we now highly recommend it for doing the process. (See equipment list at bottom of page for vendor). |
|
LET glycerin SETTLE: It will not be pure glycerin, because some of the sodium hydroxide (NaOH/Lye) will be with it. There will also be some methanol in it. |
|
DRAIN OFF glycerin: Turn the stopcock so the glycerin drains out. glycerin can be saved to be used for other purposes. It is used in hand lotion and as leather cleaner. This glycerin has some contamination with NaOH and methanol, but the NaOH can be neutralized and the methanol will evaporate. If you test it with pH paper you will find that it is alkaline (basic) with a pH around 10. The NaOH can be neutralized with a little lemon juice to get it around a pH of 6 or 7. |
|
DRAIN OFF glycerin(2): Here is another photo of the glycerin being drained off from the biodiesel. If the biodiesel is made from animal fat like lard, the biodiesel will be clear, but the glycerin will still be a dark gold color. When used oil is used, the glycerin will carry much of the burnt particles of food (particles too small to be captured by the filter) and will be black in color. The biodiesel (top layer) will have some glycerin, methanol, and sodium hydroxide (lye) residue. After most of the glycerin separates, we will proceed by adding water to the biodiesel to wash it. |
|
RECOVER METHANOL: Biodiesel is heated in a flask that's in a water bath. The water is brought up to just below boiling. Methanol will evaporate and condense in the center tube (condenser). It will collect in the left flask. The glycerin layer will also have some methanol in it. So distillation of the glycerin can recover some additional methanol. (more details will be added later) |
|
This is where people either choose water washing, Magnesol dry wash, or a combination of the two. Water washing is shown below. Magnesol works best if the methanol is distilled from the biodiesel first. (More information on Magnesol washing will be added later). | |
ADD WATER FOR WASHING: Now pour in tap water. About half a liter is good. The exact amount is not critical. Distilled water is not as good as tap water. The water needs some dissolved salts in order to better separate from the biodiesel. Again, we are trying to get rid of any residue of glycerin and sodium hydroxide. Both of these can be harmful in an engine.
|
|
USE AIR PUMP TO MIX WATER AND BIODIESEL: The water will sink to the bottom. To stir it we use an aquarium air pump(bottom of photo) to pump air through plastic tubing into the separatory funnel. The air will bubble through the mixture and effectively stir it. The end of the tubing has a weight on it to help it sink down to the bottom for better stirring. After about 3 minutes turn off the air pump. Hopefully the water and biodiesel will separate. |
|
WHAT TO DO IF EMULSION FORMS: Once in awhile the water and biodiesel will form an emulsion and not separate. The emulsion can last for days. To break up the emulsion, we add table salt to the mixture. About a half teaspoon is enough. Add the salt and mix it again by turning on the air pump for a few minutes. Turn on the air pump and let is sit. Usually the mixture will start separating in a few minutes. When the oil is getting converted to biodiesel by the methanol/lye mixture, some of the oil is getting converted to soap by the lye. The soap will tie the water and biodiesel layers together to make an emulsion. The salt you add will interfere with the soap (like hard water does) and break up the emulsion.
|
|
ALLOW WATER TO SEPARATE: After the aquarium air pump mixes the mixture for about 3 minutes, you can turn off the pump and let the water and biodiesel separate. By the way, the small flask in the upper left is the glycerin.
|
|
DRAIN OFF WASH WATER: Drain off the water that was used to wash the biodiesel. If you check the water with pH paper, you will find that it is very alkaline (pH of 12 or higher). That means the water has extracted some of the lye (sodium hydroxide) from the biodiesel, which is good. Add some more water and wash the biodiesel a second time. The second wash water will be a lower pH (around 10). The third wash is usually fairly neutral (pH around 7) meaning that most all of the lye has been washed away from the biodiesel. |
|
DRY THE BIODIESEL: After the wash water has been drained away, the biodiesel has traces of water in it. That water needs to be removed before the biodiesel can be used in an engine. If you are not in a hurry, air can be bubbled through the biodiesel (use the aquarium pump) for a couple of days. However, for our demonstrations, we let the biodiesel drip quickly through some folded paper towels (in the funnel) and then through a column (tube) containing cotton balls and Drierite as a backup to the paper. The Drierite will turn from blue to pink as it absorbs water. If Drierite at the bottom of the column turns pink, then biodiesel still has some water in it and should be filtered twice. What we see in the large flask is the final "liquid gold"; the biodiesel ready to be used in a diesel engine. |
|
USE YOUR BIODIESEL: This is the truck of one of the students who took our biodiesel class. You can see why he is interested in making his own diesel fuel. His truck holds about 100 gallons of fuel. | |
LIQUID GOLD BEING USED: Jerry is adding the biodiesel we made during the class to the truck. Yes, our half gallon would not go far in this big rig, but it proves people can make their own diesel fuel. The owner of the truck went on to buy a large scale production system. |
|
WHEN READY, SCALE UP TO LARGE SCALE PRODUCTION: The student who owned the truck above bought this system to make large batches of biodiesel. It's a nice setup, and everything learned in the small scale production taught above applies to large scale production. There are some other issues when dealing with large scale production, but the main procedure is the same. |
|
THE PROMISE OF BIODIESEL: Yes, you can make your own biodiesel for your car, but we recommend that you start with small scale production like shown in this tutorial. We think you should use real chemistry labware to make the process more efficient, safer, and more visible. If you have any questions, you can contact me, Ken Costello, at costello@chemistryland.com. Later, I will cover how to do this process with used oil and how to recover excess methanol. For those interested, I will show more of the chemistry. I also may assemble extra kits and make them available for purchasing. |
|
Below is an equipment list for the items mentioned above. What I don't show yet is the distillation equipment. | |